Compare Two Options Without Order Bias

I need to choose between two options and I want a fair comparison. The order I list them in, or the one I seem to lean towards, shouldn't decide it.

What I'm deciding: [the decision and the deadline]
What matters, most important first: [your criteria]
Option one: [first option, with the facts you have]
Option two: [second option, with the facts you have]

Show your work for each step:
1. Judge option one alone. For each criterion, a score from 1 to 5 and one line of evidence from what I wrote. Don't mention option two.
2. Judge option two the same way, as if you'd never seen option one.
3. Compare them with option two presented first: the winner on each criterion and overall.
4. Compare them again from scratch with option one first.
5. If steps 3 and 4 disagree anywhere, say where, then settle it from the scores and evidence in steps 1 and 2.
6. Decide. Name the winner, how big the gap is (clear, narrow or a tie), the strongest case for the other option and the one fact that would flip the result.

Use only the facts I gave you and label any guess as a guess. If a criterion can't be judged from what I wrote, leave it unscored and say what you'd need. Don't tell me both are good. Pick one, and if it's a genuine tie, tell me what would break it.